Content

Research

Inflammation and cell death control by linear ubiquitin chains

Post-translational modifications of proteins add up fine tunes on the signal regulations. Among them, ubiquitin modification (ubiquitination) is one of the most sophisticated ones because of its 3-step enzymatic regulation. Depending on the combinations of enzymes, ubiquitin can built up different linkage types of chains on the target proteins. Due to the complexity of regulation in ubiquitination, understanding of its role in physiological conditions is not yet completed. We try to dissect how certain types of ubiquitination play a role in pathological conditions including inflammation and cell death.

What are ubiquitin chains?

As the name says, ubiquitin is a small protein expressed ubiquitously. Ubiquitination occurs on the Lys residues of the target proteins through enzymatic actions of E1 (activating enzyme), E2 (conjugating enzyme) and E3 (ligase) (Figure 1A). Interestingly, ubiquitin itself has 7 Lys that can be used for ubiquitination, leading 7 different homotypic-linkages of chain formation (Ikeda, EMBO Rep, 2008, Figure 1B).
It is probably possible that the substrates are modified by ubiquitin chains with a mixture of different linkage types or by branched chains in vivo (Figure 1C). Each of the chain types possesses a very distinct structure (Figure 1D), which contributes to their own unique protein networks (Ikeda, Cell, 2010). To our surprise, ubiquitin recently was found to form linearly-linked (Met1-linked/ head-to-tail/ tandem repeated) chains under a specific condition (Rahighi, Cell, 2009, Ikeda, Nature, 2011, Figure 1B).

How are linear ubiquitin chains created?

These chains are produced by a ligase complex called LUBAC (linear-ubiquitin assembly complex). LUBAC was originally found to contain 2 proteins, HOIP with catalytic centre and HOIL-1L. We recently discovered SHARPIN as the 3rd component of LUBAC (Ikeda, Nature, 2011, Figure 2A). HOIP is the E3 ligase with a catalytic centre in its RBR (Ring-Between-Ring fingers) domain. Interestingly, HOIP requires one of the adaptor molecules, SHARPIN or HOIL-1L for the E3 ligase activity (Figure 2B). Even though ubiquitin has been studied intensively in the last decade, it is not yet well understood how RBR type E3 ligase functions enzymatically.
One of our focuses is to clarify how the enzymatic action of LUBAC is controlled. By clarifying the regulatory mechanism, we aim to identify novel RBR-type E3 ligases, which generate linear ubiquitin chains.

What do linear ubiquitin chains do in physiology?

A concept of linear ubiquitin chains is just about to be spread in the ubiquitin filed. Our SILAC-based mass spectrometry analysis showed that a concentration of linear ubiquitin chains in cells is relatively low in comparison to other linkage types (Ikeda, Nature, 2011). This suggests that linear ubiquitination is tightly regulated to function in specific conditions. So far, the only known condition where linear ubiquitin chains play a role is inflammatory responses (Figure 3A, B, and C).
We aim to deepen our knowledge in inflammatory and cell death signalling that are controlled by linear ubiquitin networks. Our major goal is to discover such specific conditions and understand ‘what linear-ubiquitin chains do in regulation of physiology’. To this end, we use combined techniques of biochemistry and genetically modified animal models (Figure 3C).

Figure 3 (click to view legend)

Figure 3. SHARPIN plays a role in regulation of inflammation. (A) SHARPIN is required for full activation of NF-kB pathway induced by TNF-a. Primary MEFs isolated from control (Het) and cpdm (SHARPIN deficient) mice were treated by TNF-a for indicated time. Total cell lysates from these cells were subjected to Western blot using anti-phospho-IkBa, anti-IkBa, anti SHARPIN, and anti-Vinculin. (B) SHARPIN and HOIP induce NF-kB activation. NF-kB reporter assay was performed in HEK293T cells by overexpressing different combinations of LUBAC components as indicated. SHARPIN+HOIP induced NF-kB activation as HOIL-1L+HOIP or SHARPIN+HOIL-1L+HOIP. (C) SHARPIN deficient mice shows a multi organ inflammatory phenotype including skin. H&E staining of skin tissue shows that Cpdm has thicker epidermis layer due to inflammation.

Figure 1 (click to view legend)

Figure 1. Models of ubiquitination and ubiquitin linkage types (A) Ubiquitination of the substrate is induced by a 3-step enzymatic action of E1 (activating enzyme), E2 (conjugating enzyme) and E3 (ligase). (B) Ubiquitin can form 8 different linkage types of homotypic chains. (C) A schematic model of a branched type of ubiquitin chain containing different linkages is shown. (D) Examples of di-ubiquitin chain structures are shown (Lys48- or Met1-linked/linear chains.

Figure 2 (click to view legend)

Figure 2. Linear ubiquitin assembly complex (LUBAC) generates linear ubiquitin chains. (A) LUBAC consists of 3 proteins, SHARPIN, HOIP and HOIL-1L. A catalytic center exists in the RBR domain of HOIP. (B) SHARPIN and HOIP generates linear ubiquitin chains in vitro. In vitro ubiquitination assay using E1, E2 (UbcH7) and E3 (SHARPIN+HOIP) shows that ubiquitin chains are generated only when SHARPIN and HOIP are included with ATP in the reaction (lane 4). Methylated ubiquitin (M) failed to generate chains. Ubiquitin chains were detected by SDS-PAGE followed by Western blot using anti-ubiquitin antibody.